Quarantine #Guilt?How About No Dalgona, No Workout, No Studies, Just Surviving the #Pandemic For Now?

The year is 2020.

The month is April.

Last month in March when the lockdowns began one after another in almost all countries of the world, things were different.

For ease of understanding, I say let’s divide the world into 3 categories of people:

  1. The wealthy class who are still googling where to buy Gucci face masks and Dior hand sanitizers.
  2. The middle class, both upper-middle class, and lower-middle class.
  3. And lastly the poor, the migrants, the homeless that are stranded without their daily wages, food, or shelter.

Since I mostly interact with the middle category of class, I am going to talk about this class among which I have noticed a weird strange phenomenon. 

So when in March 2020 when the lockdowns began, people saw the opportunity as an untimely vacation. Some were looking forward to the nonstop sex they were going to have, others were excited to play video games all day. Women knew the amount of housework/unpaid domestic labor that’s up ahead and probably puked (I am assuming).

womens work in pandemic But I digress.

 

Nonetheless, there was excitement.

You could see celebrities learning how to wash a mug.

Others were throwing work out challenges so that when in summer, finally the lockdowns ease, you could come out with a sculpted body.

Some idiots were busy making the same whipped up coffee Indian moms have been making for decades, calling it Dalgona or something.

Others were showing off their singing, guitar playing, dancing and other talents online in the effort to stay relevant and entertain the bored people.

Then there were the ones baking bread for the time cause of the shortage.

And then the school going students trying to figure out online classes and sticking with the homework.

The bitter Ph.D. and Masters students super excited about the number of papers and thesis chapters they would be finishing amidst the lockdown, hoping this isolation would finally get the distractions like Money Heist or McDonald’s Drive Through to stop.

It seemed like this pandemic is some sort of talent or productivity competition and you had to come out of it as the best version of yourself or Ryan Gosling or Kiera Knightly.

BUT ALAS! 

Just by the time the third week began, things began to feel different.

All the sex that was anticipated once now feels like another chore; who is going to wash the sheets after and who is going to make the condom run to the local pharmacy amid the lockdown and streets becoming a Police State. Just too much trouble to go through for a few minutes of pleasure.

And all the recipes and grand baking and cooking techniques, well let’s just say peanut butter or grilled cheese sandwich and for Indians- dal chawal roti is all you can depend on because of the food rations and poultry supply being halted.

The dancing, singing, and other talents are better now when you lie back on the couch and someone else dances for you.

Forget the frothy coffee that was giving you the arm pains, just get the coke out of the fridge or drink cold milk if at all available.

That’s where we are at. All the plans you made, all the futuristic goals, didn’t stay. Guilt has taken over now because all the things you planned and the commitments you made to yourself, you realize you are slacking behind and missing deadlines…

There is anxiety. Some days you just wake, stare at the walls, eat, play with your phone or watch FRIENDS on repeat, and go back to sleep again.

frnds

You are getting frustrated with your spouse and the kids are driving you crazy.

The thesis and research plans…went out the window.

And there is more guilt coming in when you see your friends’ insta stories from morning to late night, working out 5000 crunches, baking French pasty from scratch, taking 15 online courses, while dancing to Nimboda Nimboda and playing the guitar with another, ending her day with 3 courses of Italian meal and is on the way to win the Nobel this year for her research in Quantum Dynamics specializing in atomic optics of the alien ants she found in her kid’s poop.

multi

Enough!!!!!

 

You want to scream but you can’t because every-fucking-one is home and can’t handle a volatile, anxious being around losing their shit.

I get it. 

That’s close to what happened to me. And now I know why that is happening with me and I know many of you; because of what this Psychologist said:

brain on yo yo

This is our brain’s very natural reaction to the pandemic out there literally taking thousands of lives.

So its OK if you didn’t finish your thesis or complete those online courses you signed up for two weeks ago.

Its OK if you don’t want to make fancy meals and some nights just eat out of a container.

Its OK if you only played video games all day.

Its OK if you put on a few pounds of weight due to the emergency chocolate, and the anxiety chocolate, or the ‘Im-bored-chocolate’ or the pandemic chocolate or the chocolate stolen from your kids or spouse, or the therapeutic chocolate.

In fact, my favorite YASS QUEEN Jameela Jamil said it best:

jameela pandemic weight

I would echo her end message: BE GENTLE WITH YOURSELF.

If you can manage to do all those things, meet your deadlines and goals… GREAT! More power to ya.

But if you can’t, then please don’t kill yourself with the guilt and get into a spiral of anxiety and depression.

We don’t need to come out of this pandemic with trophies or whatever, we just need to survive it. The rest can wait.

Sending you my best wishes, stay home, stay safe, and have a blessed Ramadan to those of you fasting from tonight onwards.

Love you.

If this lockdown feels horrible to you, can you imagine living in the same house with a rapist Chacha / Uncle?

So, a young woman reached out to me a night ago and shared her story anonymously.

This young woman is independent professional living in a metropolitan in India. As a child, she recalled living in a small village somewhere in central India in a large joint family.

From class 5th to 8th, she was raped by her chacha. As a child, she had no idea what he was doing but what she remembers to this day is the FEAR. He would draw her away into a room in isolation and make her do all sorts of nasty things. This chacha was one of those elderly respected people in the family who your parents make you feel scared of as this person may be strict or violent etc.

This girls’ parents also used to scare her with that Chacha’s name when they wanted her to do her homework or finish her food. Only, they didn’t know the real reason why she was scared of him. This man himself has two daughters slightly younger than her and a wife who he abuses, calls b-word, in public, so imagine the terror of this man.

At some point even when the abuse stopped, he never showed regret or remorse, rather to this date tries to make lewd sexual remarks at her when he finds her in isolation even for a moment. When she displays anger, he starts hanging around and forcibly touching her 6 years younger sister while giving her threatening looks (to convey the message that if she shows anger or opens her mouth, his next victim will be her baby sister)!

At this point, quite understandably you would want to know WHY DIDN’T SHE TELL HER PARENTS? I know because I too was curious if the family knows anything at all.

Let’s talk about the FATHER first.

No, she has NOT told her father and she probably never could. If her father ever came to know about this, there will be either one of these two situations and I want you to tell me WHAT WOULD YOU DO knowing these situations.

Situation A: She tells her father that she was raped as a child by her Chacha. He DOESN’T believes her because that Chacha is the man he knows from way longer and is the man around whom he has spent his entire life. He already thinks this daughter of his is rowdy, bold and angry so she is probably making this up to create a storm in the family. He forcefully arranges a marriage and sends her to the first bidder before this gets out and the family honor is ruined! Mind you this is upper caste, wealthy family in a small village where child marriage is rampant and this girl having an education and job in a metro city is already ‘too much liberty’ in the eyes of rishtedaar.

Situation B: Her father believes her! But then what? He might get angry enough to actually murder his brother? What then? Her father goes to jail and their family is scattered. If the father doesn’t kill his own brother, he has to hang out and live side by side with this man for eternity. Knowing that this is your daughter’s rapist, what father would survive and not get a heart-attack living in this situation?

To your surprise, she didn’t CRY while giving me details of the abuse and the things that bastard did to a 10-year-old child.

You know when she CRIED? While talking about her father.

She said that later in her teenage years when she got some freedom to leave the house on her own, she would often spend long durations outside the home and often come home at about 9pm.

Fro this defiance of house rule to be home before dark, her father would get angry and beat her up.

She thought to herself that first she was SAFER OUT IN THE STREET than in her own home where the rapist was a few feet away.

And secondly, getting BEAT UP by your father for 10 minutes is better than getting raped for another day.

She CRIED, telling me that when her father used to beat her up, she would have that pain stock up inside her but she would always be afraid that if she ever told her father the REAL REASON WHY she likes to stay away from the home, the SHEER GUILT would destroy her father, and she wept profusely.

To all the people in the HANG THE RAPIST BRIGADE… Just tell me this-

Knowing that the rapist is the victims’ Chacha, would the family let her REPORT the rape or would they make her shut her mouth?

NOW LET’S TALK ABOUT THE MOM:

For years she didn’t tell her mother about any of this.

Recently her mother has been convincing her to get married. For natural reasons, this girl, like every other survivor of abuse, has TRUST ISSUES as well as INTIMACY ISSUES.

She wanted her mother to understand that she needs someone who would respect her physical space and consent because if one more man exercises his physical power over her for rape, she would NOT be able to cope, she might even kill herself.

Her mother’s reaction was “ok, whatever happened is in the past, let’s not talk about it”.

There was no sympathy, no empathy, no disbelief or belief.

The girl herself has no idea why her mom acted the way she did and at first, instance neither did I.

But on deeper thought, I think it is about the concept of shame and honor.

She didn’t want to discuss or encourage her daughter to discuss this because she is aware that if such a thing gets out:

The father would have to either kill his brother or feel like a failed father by hanging out with the daughter’s rapist for the rest of his life.

Everyone in the large, high profile, upper-class Hindu family would blame the girl and she will be considered ‘damaged goods’ as they say in conservative societies.

Either way, this would NOT help the daughter in any way now that this is from the past. So, better swallow the pain. Also, there may be another reason.

She said her ‘BADEY PAPA’ and his team of cousins and friends GANG RAPED the poor Dalit woman who used to pick GOBAR at their place because they were all ZAMINDARS.

That poor young woman was paid off after she told about it to the son of BADEY PAPA and many other people and no one ever saw the inside of a police car let along with jail.

So maybe the mother knows how the men in this family treat women so better keep things hush hush and not draw attention to their daughter who would be tagged as the characterless, problematic, drama queen in the family.

So here is my QUESTION TO THOSE ARGUING YESTERDAY and all others in general:

You are CURRENTLY UNDER LOCKDOWN RIGHT?

CONSIDER IF YOU HAD YOUR RAPIST LIVING WITH YOU… WHAT WOULD THAT FEEL LIKE? KNOWING THAT YOUR RAPIST IS JUST A FEW FEET AWAY FROM YOU…

AND NOW IMAGINE IF YOU WERE 10 YEARS OLD AND LIVED WITH THE RAPIST AND WEREN’T ALLOWED TO GO ANYWHERE? What would that be like?

She cried and cried when I asked why she got beaten but never told her father why she was avoiding getting home. And then I realized and said “Beti ka DIL hai na”… No daughter wants to see her father live and die with a pang of guilt this big… The guilt that he failed to protect his own little princess from the monster that lived with them in their house. And this monster is still alive and lives with her parents and every time she visits home, she faces him. Still.

There is no GYAN and no discussion here today. I just want you ALL to imagine being in this girl’s shoes… Imagine living with a rapist who you can never complain about and never send to jail. Who still has so much power, he can threaten to rape your younger sister if you open your mouth. Just imagine being this girl. Imagine how she would have experienced ‘men’ and ‘sexuality’. What would she feel like if she ever gets in an isolated with any man? Imagine if she shared this with some man she trusted and he then used her trauma against her? Imagine living with a heavier than a thousand-tonne weight ON YOUR SOUL for the rest of your life. Just do that for today.

 

 

Dear ‘Liberal’ Men, When It Comes To Women, Most of You Are No Better Than Right-Wing Sexists #CyberAbuse

Muhammad Arif  says “I wish you get a husband like him…”

Maninder Pal Singh says “…from which state u want MLA ticket?”

Mahfooz Alam  is reminding her “you remembered girls’ phone tapping incident???”

Mustaqim Shaikh making another personal remark “tumhe modi ke jaisa hi pati mile”

Sadath Ali says “and bhakti k be seema hoti hai. desh jalra ha hai economy dubra ha hai. phir mi modi k pooja kara h ho. sharam karo behen sharam karo”

I shared an article in a progressive, liberal Facebook group that I am a member of.

The article was about trying to understand why Modi continues to win the majority despite having blood on his hands. The purpose of the article was not to blindly praise Modi but analyze the propaganda machinery that has worked tirelessly to create this larger than life image of a mere government servant.

5

Hatred, of course, is dumb and blind.

Instead of reading the article and understanding the context of it, some morons began to comment as if this is a Modi praise article.

A young woman made some comments about other reasons why Modi lovers are such die-hard fans. And there comes the sexist tornado of personal remarks and attacks.

Thrice I had to intervene and beg the idiots to stop harassing this woman Priya Rai who was merely adding to her analysis of why Modi fans behave the way they do. But the comments kept pouring in.

In another incident, a young woman actively sharing her political (informative) articles in the group was targeted viciously. In one of her posts or comments, she was barely criticizing a political leader. Some idiot in the group took screenshots of it and spread it in some other propaganda group pro that political leader and claimed that this woman is calling for the assassination of the said leader.

Hate comments, death threats, and rape threats began pouring in on her DM and profile in hundreds.

Shit got so real, she had to de-activate her profile completely because it was being mass reported too and she could lose her account. She was told she could be the ‘next Gauri Lankesh’, the journalist assassinated in 2017.

Some idiot was asking her ‘rates’ claiming she was a prostitute.

At first, she took it as regular trolling, that we women are all too familiar with. But when she saw some posts with hundreds of comments calling for her lynching, she was scared beyond words can explain. She has not been able to sleep or work or focus on anything since.

When I asked, she hopelessly said that she does not think women will be safe on the internet ever and not just the paid trolls but even regular guys know how to shut women up too well by threatening them with rape.

Normally when I talk about cyberbullying or online abuse, I hide the names of the culprits but I didn’t on this post because this is a teachable moment. When you see this particular guy made such and such comments, you put a face to that faceless anonymous abuser.

As men, you have a responsibility to hold fellow men accountable since you jump so quickly on the #NotAllMen wagon. Not all men, right? So prove you are not one of them abusers. Show us, women, that you stand by us when we are harassed online or offline.

Yes, we know not all men rape, abuse or attack women with acids.

But most of you look the other way when personal attacks are made on a woman in a so-called liberal, progressive group.

And don’t even get me started on the sexist bullshit I receive on most of my posts. Rarely ever you’d see a guy standing up to the sexist trolls and that’s where the problem lies.

That is what you need to fix if you claim to have better ways of treating women in your circles than the conservative right wingers.

Dear Men, You Suck In Bed & Not In A Good Way: 3 Reasons Orgasm Inequality Exists in India

giphy
So, us Indians collectively lost our shit (excluding me and others like me, of course), when we saw Swara Bhaskar pleasuring herself in Veere Di Wedding.

The same happened after the Netflix film ‘Lust Stories’ was featured in which one of the 4 stories was about an unsatisfied newlywed, trying to pleasure herself.

But this post is NOT about self-pleasuring, it is about ORGASM INEQUALITY and why it exists.

According to the Global Sex Survey conducted by Durex in 2017, nearly 70% of women in India don’t orgasm every time they have sex. … “Orgasm is still considered as a tabooed topic in Indian society,” said Bobby Pawar, Chairman & Chief Creative Officer, Havas Group

Let me get straight into the points:

1- Slut-shaming a woman that says she wants sex or is unsatisfied

I remember some Anty of mine vaguely describing her newly-wed experience. As a bride, she was unable to consummate her marriage because they lived in a joint family. There was no privacy, and whatever little bit there was, it was barely enough to get the act done.

tumblr_m2v6av1iaN1qlzsfyo1_500

Her husband would initiate the act, do whatever would grant him the quickest way to pleasure and runoff. I asked her why didn’t she initiate the act or get intimate with him and she looked at me with shock and horror.

“Are you crazy?” she said as she covered her ears and head in shame, “ladkiya kabhi khud thodi kehti hain ye sab”!!! She dismissed my suggestion.

tenor

My teenage naivety wasn’t letting go, “lekin kyu phoopi?” 

She nodded her head with an eye roll “sari zindagi ‘behsharm’ hone ke taaney thodi sunna hai bitiya!”

What she was saying is that neither can a woman initiate the act of sex, nor she can talk about it or ask for pleasure because if she did, her husband would forever address her as a shameless woman, a whore, slut and other dirty words that are considered not worthy of respect in our beloved ‘Indian’ culture.

tumblr_inline_mqgfq0yoXd1qz4rgp540

I hope that this same burden of shame and guilt is not carried down the generations but sadly, the ground reality is that in many homes this is still a reality.

Until the day comes that we stop seeing ‘sex’ as something to be ashamed of and see it just as a need of the body, nothing can change.

The more we normalize it, the more men need to know that women are humans just as you and our anatomy require more pleasuring than that of men. I am not going to give a tutorial here on how to pleasure your woman but forget pleasure, the most important thing is to not humiliate her for having desires. 

tenor (1)

2- Lack of sex education or ‘sex-positive’ attitude 

Irony died a thousand deaths with this one- Indians, the people that literally wrote the book on sex positions, the Kamasutra, is one of the most sexually repressed people on the planet. Our attitude toward sex or sexuality is pathetic.

628

We lose our shit on Valentine’s Day or even normal days when we see a young unmarried couple in a public space.

386338

Why is it a crime to fall in love? Why is it a crime to have relationships and get to know people?

Our parents’ generations were advocates of ‘arranged marriage’s and their lives were damn depressing. Except for my own parents, I rarely see older couples having great chemistry. If their relationship is that shitty in public, imagine how awful it would be indoors!

Our people have no concept of sex-positivity. They freak out when anyone even talks of sex education. They think sex education means teachers will tell children to go and have sex.

Until this bullshit ideology towards sex education changes, women are not getting a happy ending.

tenor (2)

3- Lack of communication 

This is key.

This is the missing element in most sexual acts that leads to Orgasm Inequality.

Obviously, when you see sex as something shameful and lack a healthy attitude towards sex, you will try to complete the act with the least amount of communication.

All women are different.

Different women enjoy different things and take different times to climax. Their rhythms also change according to their ovulation cycle.

If you don’t talk to her about her body, how would you ever know?

This is why so many women say that sex for them is not about the size but about what you do with what you got.

If you don’t know how to use it efficiently and properly, then your organ is useless for her, sorry.

Sex conversations can be awkward and embarrassing and challenging. This is why it makes sense to have sex with people you trust, understand and know they will respect your boundaries. Make safe words, follow her breathing, feel her body movements…

It’s all there.

So, there you go, I just told you how to NOT SUCK IN BED IN A BAD WAY.

giphy (1)

I wish happy endings to all the unsatisfied ladies out there.

You Want Socio-political (religious) Change, But Do You Have The Patience For It? (Saving Oppressed Muslim Women)

The degradation of our environment is horrendous!

Minority rights are being denied day after day.

The rise of the far-right in the world all over is scary.

You want all the nonsense, all the shit going on in the world fixed. Me too.

But social change requires a million things out of us and PATIENCE is the most important one.

For the last couple of days, in the DRS group, I have been reading a lot about the extremist scriptures from Hinduism and Sharia, in the CONTEXT OF WOMEN’S RIGHTS.

Being a Muslim Feminist, I found this as a fantastic opportunity to observe both sides of the coin: the people trying to make the change and on the other side the people whose religious sentiments easily get hurt.

The posts attracted tons of comments (because people get easily emotional about religious sentiments) in comparison to posts about sanitation, climate change, and education policies. A lot of this involved hate comments or labeling which I guess is the collateral damage of free speech over social media.

giphy (8)

But overall, the observation reminded me of a TED Talk I had watched in 2015, of a Baloch Pakistani young woman named Khalida Brohi fighting against ‘honor killing’s in her region.

Now, before you jump on the anti-national wagon, and question why I couldn’t think of any other example; here is why…

Khalida’s story has super important pointers about making social change.

She was 18 when she discovered Facebook and decided to campaign, rally against ‘honour killings’ in her tribal, conservative Islamist region.

She failed monumentally when the local people got offended and destroyed her property, threatened to kill her. (She says that was natural and she is right).

75Po

The point in this talk that stayed in my mind, five years later is that YOU CANNOT MAKE SOCIAL CHANGE AMONG THE PEOPLE OF A COMMUNITY BY:

  1. Belittling or condescending them.
  2. Telling them how you are the most evolved one and they are unevolved.
  3. Standing in direct opposition to their CORE VALUES.

This is the MANTRA FOR ANY SOCIAL CHANGE that you ever wish to see.

It definitely helps when the person trying to make the change IS FROM THAT COMMUNITY because when you criticize from the outside, you might often not understand the full extent of their practices and beliefs and even if you do and you talk about them with utmost best intentions, it is easier for the people to dismiss you thinking ‘oh she/he is not one of us’ hence it is an attack on our beliefs. Coming from that community also helps in terms of the ‘savior complex’ which people of privilege often suffer from. There also internalized biases that all of us are capable of holding instead of factual criticisms.

I cannot speak for other religions but from the Islamic point of view, just like in Khalida’s talk, people did not need to become atheists in order for women to have human rights or advance as communities. What they needed was a reminder of the core values that get muddied under the patriarchal systems.

giphy (7)

Hence, she and her team apologized to those people. Asked to be accepted and offered an opportunity to make it up to the people.

Why did they do that?

Because it was her own community, her own people. You cannot abandon your own roots, regardless of how patriarchal or oppressive, they are. Many people do. But people like me, people like Khalida Brohi whose mission is to bring about actual change on the ground, we have got to REACH THE PEOPLE AT THE LEVEL IN WHICH THEY LIVE; IN WHICH THEY CAN RECEIVE YOUR MESSAGE.

Yes, this time it worked. Because they made it a point to engage with people’s own culture, music, art, fables in order to bring about social change.

Was it easy? No. Did it take a lot more time, patience, hard work and strategy? You bet your sweet ass it did. But did it work? A BIG FUCKING YES!

And just before you think this is all, came the next hurdle.

giphy (6)

The men in the community began to notice the change in wives and daughters… their confidence, their income capabilities, their talents… and as always, it threatened men and immediately they started stopping their women from participating in these programs.

Was it the end of social change?

No, of course not. It was time for the next strategy. It was time to up the alley, it was time to make the women’s handicrafts an official business so now men had to trade their fragile egos with lucrative women empowerment. 

Did that work? Hellll, yeah! 

Islamic scriptures are centuries old and today in various parts of the world, are followed by people all over the globe in various versions. The traditions are also mixed with specific cultural practices of specific regions and the melody and mash-up are just too complicated for an individual to understand. So, people pick and choose things that make sense to them, that they feel to be relevant in their lives and in this modern age.

What’s interesting is that in order to bring about change in the condition of women, feminism did not have to forgo Islam, instead, it became INTERSECTIONAL so women could accommodate their connection with God, along with human rights or women upliftment. This could be done because, in many ways, even those old scriptures have stood the test of time in terms of having outside home employment, riding camels and horses alongside men at wars, not being forced to take the husbands surname after marriage, writing your own terms and conditions for your Nikah and divorce, etc, just to name a few.

651cf7dcdf73c21e3e4010e90da44285

Undeniably there are plenty of other things like polygamy or half valued testimony of women that need upgrading. But just like Khalida’s story, these or any other Islamic or cultural (not actually Islamic) practices are to be challenged,  it has to be done at the ground level and by taking the people in confidence; not by mocking them.

To this point, I am so proud to see so many Muslim Feminists all over the globe, from small indigenous tribal communities like the Baloch in Pakistan to super Islamic countries like Saudi Arabia where women like Manal al-Sharif live, women are standing up for their rights and challenging the patriarchal ancient customs that are laid upon them. And none of them had to give up their faith in order to work for women empowerment.

hqdefault

A very common myth on the outer side (thanks to Western media and now Indian media too) is that Muslim women are oppressed and don’t have a voice. This statement would hold true in almost every country, every religion, everywhere in the world to various degrees. And as an outsider, if you really care about the conditions of Muslim women, here is what to do instead of head-on attacking the people’s faith or CORE VALUES:

  • Google ‘Muslim Feminists’ in the world and pick 5.
  • Follow their work, their campaigns, social media.
  • Talk to other people about their accomplishments.
  • Watch their work closely and send them messages of encouragement.
  • Help them out in whatever way you can.
  • Join their campaigns if you can and help them out with strategies, resources or ideas.
  • Most importantly, INSTEAD OF TALKING OVER THEM, be an ally and let them be their own voice. 

Khalida was the privileged one in her story, the one with knowledge and education of these oppressive cultural practices, but in her experience, neither talking AT THEM helped, nor TALKING OVER them helped.

What helped was showing genuine intent of helping those people, meeting them at a level they can understand (and not feel threatened) and ENABLE them to find their voices, learn about their rights, gradually dismantle those archaic practices with their own hands.

giphy (5)

After I learned about FEMINISM and evaluated my whole life against it, I wanted to scream out loud at the top of my lungs how things were wrong and injustices against women were happening all over the world.

I began writing blogs, books published. But that was the knowledge, on paper, not much was changing on the ground.

giphy (4)

So I began helping women through my blog in other ways.

I would hear their stories, point them towards doctors, lawyers, therapists, whatever resources they were in need of.

Sometimes, I also helped them financially, for example, to get out of violent husbands’ homes.

Informed them of their rights under the Sharia law, according to which they were married in the first place.

I talked about sensitive issues on my YouTube channel so people could use that to get validation and support.

I DISMANTLE the oppression with my Muslim community, among cousins, friends, neighbors, blog readers, book fans and internet strangers by MEETING THEM WHERE THEY ARE instead of challenging their entire belief system.

Is this all I could do? Perhaps more but I am only human and still learning social change.

I am still trying to find better ways, sharper strategies to bring about change in women’s lives, not just in my community but the world all over, but I have to make peace with these few things;

  1. Social change moves at glacial speed, so don’t expect things to change overnight.
  2. Probably in my lifetime, gender gaps won’t be closed and women won’t have equal rights as that of men.
  3. I can’t change a person or their opinion unless I find something in common with them (sometimes it could just be our humanity, an important negotiation technique I learned in my Swiss Business School).

Should I stop trying because it was too hard and too exhausting?

I would probably die if I stopped. I do this because it gives me purpose to live.

I am in it for the surprises, NOT the PRIZES.

For me, a simple thank you from a distressed, domestically abused woman is enough.

giphy (3)

That overused, cliched story holds true- the one with the grandfather and the kid walking past by the shore and the kid throwing back fishes into the water that were left stranded on the shore by the waves. And the grandpa laughs and asks the kid “there are millions, how many would you throwback and what difference would it make?”

And the kid replies “it makes a difference to the one fish that is back in the water”!

Total cliche, I know, but I can’t help but feel exactly the same way. The war on social injustice is strenuous and sinister at best, tiring and life draining at worst. But if you are reading this long piece, I have faith that you care about the world and the injustices happening around, and you are working day and night to stand up for the rights of some people, whether or not they acknowledge your efforts.

HOW DOES THIS PLAY OUT IN THE WORLD OF SOCIAL MEDIA?

Over social media, the chances of someone coming to a Twitter feud and walking away with enlightenment is UNHEARD of. The same applies to Facebook.

2617eae633b2eef8aae43f9cccea5208

So how do we expect to bring about any change if our audience is on social media?

The honest answer is I DON’T KNOW because if I did, I would have an army uprising for me right now.

But the basic premise from Khalida’s story that we can learn are the ones I already mentioned in the beginning: that YOU CANNOT MAKE SOCIAL CHANGE AMONG THE PEOPLE OF A COMMUNITY BY:

  1. Belittling or condescending them.

  2. Telling them how you are the most evolved one and they are unevolved.

  3. Standing in a direct challenge to their CORE VALUES.

If you do even one, you won’t be making any social changes but inviting nonsensical debates from people that did not understand your intentions.

giphy (1)

Now also a thing to be noted is that this is a general approach to a tribal, uninhibited people.

unnamed

It does not apply to fundamentalist politicians, right-wing supporters, and leaders.

That’s because leaders, politicians are privileged people in power that are voted by democratic masses, and their job is to be secular and unbiased (no racist sexist shit can go down).

I also include supporters of the majority (often right-wing type) party supporters because in Khalida’s example we were talking about challenging only cultural/religious practices. 

However, in the other one, there isn’t just religion but political ideologies. And political ideologies do not work on the same principles. Politicians use fake news, propaganda, fear-mongering, hate speeches, polarization, inciting communal riots, and several other sinister tactics to keep the voter scared enough to vote for them. And these change state after state, politician after politician.

giphy (2)

Bringing about social change in the political area is something way harder (in my opinion) because of the awe-inspiring, larger than life image created by media for the politicians. And until and unless your very own existence comes under threat, your own women raped on the streets and your own life savings taken over by a bankrupt bank; it is hard to give a crap and understand how the minorities feel.

giphy

There are people, plenty of privileged people who stand up for minority rights, challenge the status quo even when it is dangerous and put their own lives at risk. But with such compassionate people, on the opposite spectrum are also the vile, vicious and violent ones. And those are the ones that will take heed with time alone, maybe by having employment opportunities that keep them busy and provide them an environment to intermingle with the very people their politicians are telling them to hate.

But that’s a distant dream, right?

dream

 

India Is On Fire & These 5 Revolution Anthems Sum it All Perfectly

Music and songs are not just for entertainment or therapy, IT’S ALSO FOR REVOLUTION!

Don’t believe me?

1: Here is the first one called POORNA SWARAJ

Composition/Arrangement – RollsRoy’s and Abhishek Sekhri Lyrics – Sumit Roy and Aman Agarwal

Your soul isn’t on fire yet?

#2 on the list is called TUKE TUKDE KAUN 

Produced, Mix & Mastered – Seven & Seven Video by Nanu Dhanotia

Oh, that just makes my blood run at the pace of Fast and Furious…

#3 on the list is called THE SHAHEEN BAGH ANTHEM SONG

Written and performed by: Maaz Musik Music: Fifty Vinc Music arrangement: Suraj Music Mixing/Mastering: Ganesh Nair Concept: Shagufta Yasmeen

I dedicate the last two to Amir Aziz, an excellent revolutionary poet, and musician. Both his works listed here are deep, riveting and hair raising.

#4 is Amir Aziz’s ACHE DIN BLUES

#5 is Amir Aziz’s SAB YAAD RAKHA JAEGA 

These revolution anthems are the voice of the Indian on the street, the real person without the privileges of political power and corrupt money. The one fighting day and night to survive, the one whose very existence is about to be uprooted with the introduction of the NRC-CAA law.

The more power this fascist government exerts, the louder these voices chime in protest and that gives me hope. That tells me the fight isn’t over.

More power to these artists, please support their work by sharing it forward, funding their projects through crowdsourced platforms and if nothing, just send them a note of appreciation. To an artist, that means the world, that’s what keeps them going when everything feels like an end.

Inquilab Zindabad. Long live the power of people!

I Used to Hate Muslim Gays. Until…

I grew up in the 90s and 2000s when the internet was still in invention mode.

Up until 20 years of age, I was not aware there is such a thing as ‘homosexuality’. Yes, some movies or TV shows had passing characters, always the butt of the joke but never the main protagonist never was anything discussed about homosexuality.

Deepa Mehta’s FIRE came out in 1996 which was highly controversial but we never got to know what it was about, that’s the level of censorship at home.

Finally, as an adult when I did learn about homosexuality, it was in the concept of hatred; something to be condemned, something to be hated and looked down upon.

Not having any personal exposure to either homosexual people or in-depth knowledge of the concept, I did not have any strong opinions on it but certainly thought this was BAD because I was told so.

In 2007, I traveled to Europe for the first time and slowly I had exposure to all kinds of people.

The most revelatory thing to me was the fact that just how being left-handed or right-handed is NOT in a person’s control or choice, similarly, being homosexual is also NOT a choice, it is something natural and people are born with it.

I thought this is a perfect time to write about this because

The UK’s first-ever Muslim LGBTQ Pride event is happening this year

After reading all the things mentioned in the Holy Quran and the Hadith regarding homosexuality, this is my own conclusion on the subject:

Allah hates Gays-

No, I don’t think Allah created anything in the entire galaxy for the purpose of hating, especially not human beings. Gay people are a creation of Allah so unless you believe that gays were created by someone else (which is shirk), Allah can never hate gays. Allah loves us all.

Allah will punish gays, so why don’t we punish them in this life too?

What is between Allah and His creation, you and I have no right to meddle with. Let Allah judge them on their deeds, you worry about yours.

No one can be Muslim and Gay at the same time.

Islam and Allah is NOT someone’s property or inheritance. Any person regardless of their sexuality can choose to worship Allah or any other God or no God at all.

So, you’re telling me there are actual Muslims that are gays?

Yes, Imaan LGBTQ is an organization that has been in existence for 20 years.

Daayiee Abdullah is a gay Imam in Washington DC.

Awhan Hermann is a gay Imam in Germany.

Imam Nur Warsamiis trying to create Gay-friendly mosques in Australia.

Ludovic Mohamed Zahed opened Europe’s first inclusive mosque 10 years ago.

Together these few Gay Muslims have done more good for the world than plenty of us combined.

What people do in their bedrooms should be their choice anyways, not ours, as long as it is between two consenting adults.

Particularly interesting is this talk by Junaid Jahangir.

Indian Muslims right now are fighting for minority rights because of the CAA-NRC thing and more than anyone else should understand how it feels when the majority tries to bully you, demonize you. If you are sensitive about minority rights as an Indian Muslim but fail to recognize the minority rights of LGBTQ people, then you don’t know how human rights work.

Families of LGBTQ people throw them out, disown them let alone the world, the workplace, and friends. Life is imminently difficult for them and by being jerks to them, you don’t become a better Muslim. We need to make our spaces, all spaces, queer-friendly and I truly hope if there are people around me that are in the closet, I make them feel safe enough to come out to me and I truly hope I never make the mistake of discriminating against them.

You could have grown up with all kinds of prejudices and biases but as you grow older, it is your job to recognize them and rectify your behavior otherwise, what’s the point of school, education, learning?

 

 

 

 

Why Can’t I Use The Racial Slurs Like ‘Bhaiyya’ Mentality, ‘Cow-Belt, Low IQ Field Shitters’ For All Hindi Belt Indians?

So for the last few weeks, I have been part of a Facebook group that shares political and social opinions and facts. It has been an interesting experience and here is something that has got me worried about the way people reduce each other to labels while bathing in a superiority complex. (Well, it’s mostly just this one person)

disgusted

This guy has been using terms like ‘bhaiyya’ mentality, cow-belt mentality, field shitters etc. Here are some of the words that disturbed me including the person justifying British atrocities on North Indians, because they ‘deserved’ it. The person uses the word ‘bhaiyya infested’, yeah!

Despite several people confronting this person, they have continued to use these words which have added nothing to any discussions.

shck

Despite this person’s so obviously blatant privilege, I am not going to talk about their (hiding gender pronoun too, on purpose to protect identity) own race, state, language or launch a comparison to demean their place of belonging or race. Firstly, I don’t know any of those things because it doesn’t matter to me and secondly, this is not a personal attack because then what would be the difference between this person and me. I am NOT A RACIST so I neither care nor bothered to show light on their own race.

Let me clarify one thing-

There is no doubt UP, Bihar and surrounding areas have high crime rates, low education rates, sexism, rampant misogyny, and awful politicians that have done little to change the horrible state of their regions. 

Me, belonging to Lucknow, the capital of Uttar Pradesh am aware of these realities all too well.

i know

Never have I ever been delusional about the condition of my state or my people. Nither have I ever defended any of those horrible things done in my state.

The fact that I am aware of and working to change those things kills that stereotype right there. And I am far from being alone. Day and night, there are several people coming from these communities that are fighting against medieval and sexist traditions in order to better their people.

The point here is not whether these regions are backward and need to change; of course, they do need to change. 

The point here is that when you label a community like this and do nothing but spew hateful rhetoric against its people, you kind of become the exact same or rather worse kind of a person because when you yourself being educated and ‘evolved’ are not willing to pick better words to address groups of people, you expect uneducated people to act all evolved and civilized?

rac

I read this somewhere on the internet that really stayed with me and is relevant here:

When a member of a group tells you to stop doing something that triggers them or to not use a racist slur, they are not violating your free speech, because they don’t have any power to stop you. You won’t be penalized in any way if you continue to do the thing that bothers them. They are simply saying that if you respected them and people like them, you would stop. By continuing, you are simply stating that YOU ARE WILLINGLY CHOOSING TO NOT RESPECT them.

This person who has been using these nasty words has been in the group from way longer than me and despite people trying to reason with them, no one has banned or penalized them. Clearly shows who is the more matured and evolved one.

This person deliberately hangs out in groups with Hindi speaking majority and instead of considering Hindi speakers as ‘fellow Indians’, they constantly make derogatory remarks about them and then expect them to act ‘civilized’. And this group works tirelessly to criticize and spread awareness about all the awful things happening in India, all of India, there is no ‘my state is paradise’ delusion there.

Another thing that I read somewhere about political correctness and people ranting that they are now being forced to ‘accept’ things they do not believe in-

So many folks talk about how they are being ‘forced to accept’ things that go against their beliefs.

You are not being forced to accept them.

If you have a problem with people of color, with gay marriage, trans people, immigrants, or people of any race, you are still welcome to feel however you want to feel about those people. You are just not allowed to make their lives harder because of your feelings. You are not allowed to turn their daily lives into a battleground. No one is ‘forcing’ you to ‘accept’ a single thing.

This person who is so openly racist against people from North India is educated and all kinds of people have tried to speak with them in the politest, calm and respectful manner and tried to investigate if they are saying all this because of their personal experiences or whatever.

hg

What makes me worried is that if this person is so openly racist in a faceless social media group, imagine how horribly racist they would be in real life to people around them?

When someone would approach them for rent?

When they would meet a colleague or a subordinate from Northern areas?

My problem with all of this is simply- call it whatever you want but does your name-calling make any positive contribution to change the issues we are fighting?

No? Then please keep your judgments/opinions/rants and racism to yourself!!!

b

Here is something else I read elsewhere that sums up the effect of this racist language on people:

It is not about trying to be overly sensitive or politically correct.

It is about having enough social awareness to realize that not every thought you have or action you take adds value to the lives of those around you and that your words may, in fact, diminish another’s personhood.

WarmSplendidAmericanbulldog-small

You NEVER have the right to diminish someone’s personhood because they come from a certain area or belong to a certain race! Never!

A Feminist’s Opinion on ‘Should Nirbhaya’s Mother Forgive The Rapists of Her Daughter’?

So, only if you live under a rock you may not know about the rape of an Indian student in 2012 that sparked international outrage and brought India to a halt. The media called her Nirbhaya.

Recently, a Supreme Court lawyer Indira Jaysingh advised or urged Nirbhaya’s mother to forgive the rapists which of course and very rightly outraged the lady.

Where does a FEMINIST stand on this?

There has been a long-standing debate on the topic of capital punishment/death penalty and whether or not such punishment would discourage future rapists.

Time and again through data, this has been proven that the DEATH PENALTY DOES NOT DETER RAPE. 

If anything, the death penalty will punishment will make things worse because now the rapist will not only rape but also murder in order to avoid any witness. The recent incidents of setting rape victims on fire is the direct consequence of this because the rapists know their DNA could be extracted. Hence the motivation to end the victim’s life is way stronger.

HUMAN RIGHTS activists and Feminists have long stood for the NO DEATH PENALTY argument because of the above reasons.

Dumb idiots who do not want to understand the full argument, immediately brand these Feminists as terrorist sympathizers or somehow think that human rights activists want to save evil people.

That being said, what this lawyer Indira Jaysing has said about forgiving Nirbhaya’s rapists is the most insensitive and outrageous thing she could have said.

First of all, it is shameful enough that it’s been 8 years and the rapists have not been punished yet.

To add to that pain, this weird notion in our society about ‘forgiveness’ is actually an extremely toxic thing to say to a rape survivor or their family members.

See, this is not Saudi Arabia where according to Sharia law if the family of the dead person pardons the murderer, the punishment is either reduced or written off.

Secondly, there is law in India. Whether Nirbhaya’s mother forgives the rapists or not, a crime has been committed and the criminals deserve the strictest punishment for such a barbaric act. The law does not run on the whims of people’s feelings.

Thirdly, in Feminist literature I often read this idea of ‘forgiving your rapist’, in fact, I have written about it in the past from my post about the famous Netflix show 13 Reasons Why. 

What I learned from Feminism is that there is absolutely no need to ‘forgive your rapist or abuser’ in order to move on. 

One therapist I was speaking to actually told me that if you have bitterness inside you or have feelings that you don’t want to face then you cannot heal. Your first step should be to face those feelings and forgive the people who wronged you.

SHE COULDN’T BE MORE WRONG!

Speaking with other learned and respectable therapists I learned that forgiving someone is only and only up to the person who has suffered the pain and in order to heal from that pain, there are plenty of other ways and ‘forgiving’ is NOT one of them.

Being a Human Rights lawyer, Indira Jaysing has not only spoken out of turn but she has emotionally abused the sentiments of Nirbhaya’s mother.

Indira Jaising is an Indian lawyer who is noted for her legal activism in promoting human rights causes. In 2018 she was ranked 20th in the list of 50 Greatest Leaders of the World by Fortune magazine. Considering her accomplishments and sensitivity on gender equality and human rights, this is shockingly upsetting that someone like her has spoken these words. 

If it was anyone else, dismissing it would be easier but considering her stature, this is unbelievably shocking.

I would argue against the death penalty in general but in this case, I won’t,  considering the barbarity of the act. But not in a million imaginations I would ever consider it OK to tell Nirbhaya’s mother to forgive those monsters.

Also, tomorrow even if Nirbhaya’s mother does forgive them for some unknown reason; the law still has to take its course. 

They did not have mercy on Nirbhaya while shoving iron rods inside her, they knew what they were doing. They deserve way worse than capital punishment.

 

Liberals Divided Over #KunalKamra Heckling #Arnab But Can #Injustice Really Be Fought When Playing By The Rules?

So, Kunal Kamra, the infamous Indian comedian broke the internet yesterday when a video of him went viral in which he is pestering/asking questions to Arnab Goswami (the government’s lapdog journalist).

Immediately within hours, Kunal Kamra was banned from flying the airline in question (despite there being no FIR or police complaints from fellow passengers or crew) and for some weird reason, several other airlines also announced a ban on Kunal.

Later Kunal issues a statement and clarified that:

a- he was NON VIOLENT throughout

b- he went to his seat when the crew asked him to

c- he apologized to the crew, pilots and fellow passengers as soon as the incident happened and his intent was NOT to bother people but to give Arnab a taste of his own medicine. 

kunal-kamra

He also explained the reason behind his outrage/emotional outburst in a video that featured many pieces of information including Arnab’s latest propaganda questioning the CASTE of late Dalit student ROHITH VEMULA which is way below the belt even by Arnab’s standards. I mean we all know he is hate spreading, right-wing communal, polarizing, biased, paid journalist but trying to take away the dignity of someone who is not even alive to defend himself anymore… speechless!

 

Then began the debate among the liberals whether Kunal ‘heckling’ Arnab in this way was fair or not. 

People favoring Arnab said that if we use such language and acts then we are no better than the right-wingers. There was a whole lot of mention of ‘politeness’ and ‘peace’ while making arguments against opponents. And of course, there was the question of invading someone’s personal space and the safety of the fellow passengers.

I have been on the edge myself because I personally believe in all these things deeply. I respect freedom of expression as much as I stand for privacy and personal space. How does one choose a side in a matter like this?

One thing that comes to mind is why. 

Arnab Goswami is an aspiring war criminal.

He has, at the top of his voice, made calls for wars.

What Kunal did to Arnab in that 2-3 minute clip, Arnab actually does that for a living and not just heckles but rips a new one to the unfortunate participants he invites on his debates. He has played a huge role in dividing the nation as Anirban DasGupta, another comedian pointed out.

Some people claimed that if “you don’t like Arnab’s journalism don’t watch it, simple!”

But the point here is that people of the right-wing and others who don’t know any better, do watch him and more importantly, journalism has very high codes of ethics and practices.

Don’t like it don’t watch it seems apt for a TikTok video maybe but not for a field that is known as one of the pillars of democracy.

Whether I watch something or not does not mean there should be no ethical standards and no role of facts in journalism!

Maybe stepping aside for a moment and looking at world history would help.

Slavery was legal.

So was a holocaust and Sati pratha.

All major mass killings, genocides happened as per the LAW or the then rules of the land.

Would Stalin, Mussolini or Hitler ever be challenged by being polite and playing according to their rules?

giphy

Gandhi was a nonviolent revolutionary but he too resisted injustice and did not play by the rules. Actually, there can be no revolution, no change, no progress if you play by the rules of the oppressor. That is the simplest logic.

In Feminist literature I read a lot about women asked to be ‘lady-like’, to be polite, subservient, play dumb, be obedient, never question authority and no woman ever made history by being polite and sweet. It was the badasses, the rule-breakers that brought about change.

202520223000202

One might then question, where do we draw the line? Or is there a line at all between the two scenarios of rule-breaking?

I would like to think there is and we all know very well where it is.

Gandhi was sent to jail several times and so were plenty of other freedom fighters for opposing the ‘law’.

If Gandhi and his team approached General Dyer with a bouquet of roses and a letter to please leave India, would he have left along with his empire?

And when Gandhi and all the freedom fighters protested and resisted, they knew they were breaking the law and they were ready to pay the price for it because they could differentiate the right from wrong.

Heckling anyone is wrong.

Compromising the safety of fellow passengers is wrong (if I were on that flight though, I would have loved this entertaining episode but that’s just me).

The language Kamra used, ‘coward’ nationalist etc, is all wrong.

But when you look at Arnab, you know this episode is not even a tiny fraction of what Arnab himself has done to others. He not only does that on a daily basis but earns a living out of it.

Shaheen Bagh protestors have been putting their arguments across peacefully, right?

The ones Arnab has been branding as anti-nationals, hate spreading and what not nonsense… Despite playing by the rules, has the protest managed to appeal to even one person in the ruling party? Have their voices which they have been raising in Delhi’s stone-cold weather for over 40 days, managed to reach the PM who was awfully worried about Muslim sisters on the matter of Triple Talaq? I am not saying they are wrong to be peaceful, in fact, their best strategy is to remain peaceful because it wouldn’t take the government a second to shut them down forcefully if one word was uttered that was NOT right (Sharjeel Imam case in point).

The right-wing has in fact been waiting madly for these peaceful protestors to make one mistake so they can be torn apart.

Repeated attempts have been made to malign them; from paid women to lazy men bla bla. However no government official has bothered to communicate once.

Other peaceful protests have been happening at universities which as of yesterday have been banned from holding protests or lectures on ‘anti-national’ activities.

The second you disagree with the government, you become a traitor and now the universities are complying blindly with the regime also. Henceforth, the protests in IIT and other such places… dead. There you go, played by rules and crushed down by the rules.

What choice is the regime leaving for people?

How do they register their agitation? By following blindly?

Peeing Human, Akash Banerjee and Dhruv Rathee have shared Kunal related posts and offered support along with Anurag Kashyap and many other famous people.

Even if we agree that the ‘heckling’ regardless of who it was against was deserving of punishment, as per the aviation/airline rules, such behavior qualifies for a 3-month ban only! Not a day more.

And only from the airline in which the incident happened. What is other airline’s business banning him when the incident did not take place in their aircraft and no one has complained? Just because the aviation minister made a Twitter suggestion, the bootlickers immediately obeyed and all this official government communication happened on Twitter!!!

Don’t even get me started on the super offensive behavior of BJP ministers that range from literally thrashing an airline crew with a shoe to tantrums for a first-class/window seat and barely ever, if any, action has been taken against them. Because they rule the country, right? But the entire government machinery and the airline industry can outcast a poor comedian because he asked provocative questions to a journalist who uses the exact same language with others.

I may not agree with Kunal Kamra’s choice of words not just from the heckling but also from his standup comedy. But I don’t disagree with the argument.

People also claimed that Kamra only did this to collect standup material. Or he only wanted to gain attention etc.

giphy (1)

Let me tell you that there are a lot many, safer and more profitable ways of doing stand up comedy (like the 98% of India’s stand up comedians) than what Kunal did which has invited such indefinite bans on him. Like Kenny Sebastian said in his standup video when asked about why he doesn’t do political comedy; he said: “I like my family and not crispy”!

Another thing why Kunal’s outburst makes sense is because this Arnab has invented this phrase ‘Tukde Tukde Gang’ and set this ‘anti-national’ narrative against Kanhaiya Kumar, Umar Khalid, Swara Bhaskar, Kunal Kamra and of course anyone who questions the government.

This Tukde Tukde narrative is not just empty words. There was an assassination attack on Umar Khalid because of this. These hateful words have powerful consequences and Umar could have lost his life. Same goes with all these other people that Arnab has declared ‘anti-nationals’. 

To be honest, if someone BRANDED me like this with fake empty words that are code for calling to my murder, I would be a lot more furious than Kunal was. Arnab has never minced his words when declaring government opponents with the worst of phrases.

Arnab has insulted Shabana Azmi, Naseeruddin Shah, and several prominent, most respectable, most legendary people just because they condemned the silence of the PM of India over mob lynchings.

This narrative led to director Anurag Kashyap’s daughter getting rape threats.

You can easily argue Arnab Goswami is NOT responsible for such rape threats or an assassination attempt on Umar Khalid. Yes, technically he didn’t do those things himself but he literally set the whole scene, didn’t he? It is like supplying the fuel, the matches, the hay, and every single thing and only not lighting the matchstick in the end.

This reminds me of PM Modi’s visit to the USA and when Hassan Minhaj tried to attend the rally.

Minhaj was banned from entering the conference because he had criticized Modi in the past.

This is what the fascist leaders do. They are so scared, they don’t even let satirists and opponents anywhere close to them because they DO NOT WANT RATIONAL DEBATE! They don’t want to answer your polite questions!

You have to take matters into your own hands by asking your questions and expressing your reaction to them (especially when they branded you as a traitor) when and where you can.

We can go on but in the end, I only want to ask one question- can polite rational argument win with hate-mongers who have branded the rest of the nation anti-national without rhyme and reason?

Can a revolution be brought about playing by the rules?

The right-wingers that have literally called for raping women of minorities, beheading Muslims, burying them alive, declaring them pests and parasites… do they care about rationality?

My fear is you become the monster you are trying to fight, sometimes. I would never want these comedians, directors, opposition to stoop so low as Arnab Goswami and question/malign deaths of people in the right-wing camp.

Liberals do that. We stood by the Delhi police when they were beaten up by goons. We expressed condolence for Kamlesh Tiwari’s murder and equally for the martyrs of Pulwama.

Neither Kunal nor any of these liberal-left people were ever seen supporting violence or celebrating murders or deaths.

However, the same has not been the case from the right-wingers. Do you speak to them in the language they understand and risk losing your humanity in the process or do you keep attempting in making rational arguments while they divide the country, sell all the national assets, kill the economy, eat taxes from the regular people and enjoy lives while branding anyone who even slightly criticized the government as a traitor?

And during the time they do all this, uncountable lives have been lost.

What is a 2 minute non-violent heckling when compared to genocide and war crimes? Equal?

I am torn. If you know how to answer this, please do.